Book Reviews

Have you read my books?

Want to write your own review?

Enjoyed Mystic City ? The author would love to feature your review! 

★★★★★

This is a very long book, but the story is so intriguing you just get sucked in, and don’t realise you’ve spent hours reading. I really loved how this book started with an introduction to vampire houses, werewolf packs and witch covens. I loved the characters, their interactions, the banter and the slow burn. The amount of world building was perfect. The book ends with a cliffhanger and the fact that we don’t know where Leila’s rabbit Blue is, is killing me. I need book two now!

– Tuliriemu

★★★★★

Mystic City blends urban fantasy, slow-burn romance, and heart-pounding mystery into an unforgettable story about love, loss, and the courage to face who you really are” This was a really good read! It was refreshing to read about a magical word where the main is a human who goes through love and loss and having to try prove herself innocent! I loved the slow burn, the world building and the companions Everything melded smoothly into each other without being confusing or overwhelming. Leila and Grim are perfection. Leia and Callaghan’s banter was beautiful, it made me laugh so much! The cliffhanger at the end was done beautifully and I cannot wait for the second book to unravel more!

– Smiley

★★★★★

Izzy has the makings of a truly epic series here, with the first instalment for Mystic City, Souls and Spirits. The concept, the twists and the lore are solid and compelling. I loved the mix of modern settings, yet still Gothic, interspersed with traditional magic yet tempered with other cultures and their beliefs. It all melts into a rich and complex system and world. There were so many great lines and so much raw emotion bleeding from the page, that you are soon sucked into Leila and Grims’ complicated story. The first chapter is a behometh, but once you are through it, the story finds its pace and Izzy’s humour and storytelling shines through. And also, I dare you not to fall in love with Callaghan and of course Grim…

– Kelsbookreads

★★★★★

The best way I can describe this book is mystical, especially considering it’s Fleay’s debut novel. It has you intrigued from the beginning wondering how a human girl, Leila, fits into a city where everyone else is a mystic (basically vampires, werewolves, wizards, and so much more). There’s mystery, banter, some steaminess, sarcasm, laugh out loud moments, and moments that just gut you. This book personally reminded me of a mix of Brooklyn 99, Crescent City, and Naruto. So if you’re a lover of any of these, this book should be right up your alley! So happy mystical reading!

– Nicole

★★★★★

This book is amazing! The mix of dark fantasy, magic, and all the emotional parts made it super immersive. Arcadia telt so real with all its history, danger, and beauty. Leila and Grim? I loved them. Their relationship wasn’t just romantic; it was deep and emotional. You could really feel their connection. Leila, as a main character, really stood out to me. I love an FMC who is not backing down from a challenge. She’s not perfect, and that’s what makes her awesome. Seeing her grow, face tough choices, and fight through everything thrown at her was so inspiring. I don’t usually read long books, but this one was 100% worth it. It picks up as it goes, and by the end, I didn’t want to stop reading.

– Marla

★★★★★

The fact that Author Izzy started Mystic City Souls and Spirits with trigger warnings is a huge green flag for me. As someone who usually struggles with longer books, I wasn’t expecting to get so hooked-but wow, I loved this read! It kept me hooked from start to finish, and I was left craving more. Yes, Chapter One is on the longer side, but don’t let that discourage you! Izzy quickly picks up the pace, and the plot is so gripping, I couldn’t put the book down. Leila is such a powerful, MFC, compassionate, her big heart and soul proves that being human doesn’t make her any less powerful than the fairies, werewolves, vampires, soul eaters, or any other mystical creatures she encounters. Then there’s Grim, who is protective and mysterious but also reveals a side of himself that’s surprisingly giving and full of heart. His love for Leila and his bond with his best friend (who’s also like a father figure to him) add such depth to his character.

– Sharnie

Testimonials

★★★★★

This was a really good book to read, it is VERY long though, but it does warn you. The mfc Leila is just a boss b***h, and I loved her character. We are left on a cliffhanger, and I am excited for book 2.

– Jess

★★★★★

Mystic City is a fun, atmospheric dive into a world where magic and monsters walk the streets, and one very human girl finds herself caught in the middle of something far bigger than she ever imagined. I really enjoyed the blend of urban fantasy and mystery here. The city of Arcadia feels alive, full of interesting creatures and hidden corners, and the soul-eating mystery adds a nice layer of suspense. Leila is a likeable protagonist with a strong voice, and Grim is the classic broody-but-intriguing character that fans of slow-burn romance will appreciate. Their dynamic had some nice moments, and while it took a bit to really get going, I was invested by the end. A solid pick if you’re craving a magical world with danger, romance, and a touch of darkness.

– Amanda

Join my newsletter

Sign up to my FREE newsletter ‘The Arcadian Post’ to receive monthly author updates, fun perks and exclusive updates!

Email:

izzyfleaywrites@gmail.com

Copyright © 2026 Isabelle Fleay. All Rights Reserved.